The Tribunal Procedure Committee is running a consultation on the reintroduction of the accelerated appeals for detained appellants. This is a surprise move given that the Fast Track Rules were quashed in 2015.
The Fast Track Rules applied a much shorter deadline than existed in the principal Rules and limited the powers of the Immigration Courts to adjourn cases. In June 2015 the High Court found that the Fast Track Rules were unlawful. Mr Justice Nicol concluded that the Fast Track Rules were structurally unfair, because their abbreviated time table, and restricted case management powers available to the Judges created a serious procedural disadvantage. The Court of Appeal agreed that the abbreviated time scales made a fair hearing impossible in a significant number of cases and the Court emphasised that speed and efficiency must not trump justice or fairness. Therefore, the Fast Track Rules were quashed and since then all immigration cases including those involving detained parties have been dealt with under the principal Rules of the First Tier Tribunal.
However, on 12th October 2016 the Ministry of Justice launched its own consultation on a proposal to expedite appeals for immigration detainees. The Government response to this consultation was issued in April 2017 and set out the Government’s view that there is a need for specific Rules in respect of appellants in detention. The Government position is that only specific Rules will achieve a guaranteed maximum time frame for the determination of detained appeals. The Government also believe that Rules should require that the decision on whether the appellant has permission to appeal to the Upper Tribunal takes no longer than 20 working days.